Raiders Trading Amari Cooper To Cowboys Encouraging In More Way Than One

Jeff Spiegel
Jeff Spiegel
7 Min Read
Jasen Vinlove-USA TODAY Sports

It’s crazy to think we’re just 21 months removed from a 12-4 Oakland Raiders team that made the playoffs behind the emergence of three budding superstars in Derek Carr, Khalil Mack and Amari Cooper. They were the envy of the league — flush with talent and in youth, with a future seemingly as bright as any franchise in the league.

And yet, in 21 short months, everything changed. That youthful foundation has been torn to the ground as the Raiders have gone full rebuild — having traded Khalil Mack just before the season and now, having moved Amari Cooper just before the beginning of Week 8. With Mack gone, the Raiders could pretend like they were still interested in competing this season — but with Cooper gone, there’s no hiding what is happening: both eyes of Jon Gruden are now firmly fixed on the future.

Which leads to some questions: did the Raiders tear down too soon? Was the Cooper move the right one? Is Derek Carr next?

Let’s tackle them one at a time.

First, while initially shocking, I’ve begun to come around on the idea of a rebuild. It’s easy to look at the front line stars and think this team was built to win — and win now, but the truth is that football is a game won by a team of 53 different players. As the year has gone on, one thing has become clear: the Raiders were nowhere near having 53 good football players.

Since drafting Carr and Mack in 2014, the Raider drafts have been simply dreadful. Here are the nine players that Oakland drafted in the first three rounds since: Amari Cooper (we’ll get to him), Mario Edwards Jr. (cut in September, he has four tackles in six games for the New York Giants), Clive Walford (cut in March, currently a free agent), Karl Joseph (not starting for the Raiders), Jihad Ward (traded to Cowboys in April, cut and then signed by the Colts), Shilique Calhoun (cut and added to the practice squad twice), Gareon Conley (five career starts), Obi Melifonwu (on injured reserve), Eddie Vanderdoes (on injured reserve).

You simply can’t build a sustainable winner with drafting like that and while I hated the Mack trade, it’s become more and more clear that this team was more than a piece or two away from truly competing. Once you realize that, you’ve got to find value and potential where you can — hence the stockpiling of draft picks (five first rounders in the next two drafts).

Which brings us to the Cooper trade — a move that was far more positively received around the league, and one that (in my book) qualified as a no-brainer. In all my years of watching the Raiders, I’m not sure I’ve followed a player more frustrating than Cooper: he’s got all the talent in the world, all the physical ability one could ever ask for — and yet he never seemed to put it all together.

You could look at his end-of-season stats and find some positives, but on a game-to-game basis, I can’t remember a single time that he took over a game the way he should be doing consistently. Instead, his career in Oakland was plagued by drops and occasional (regular) Sunday no-shows. So with all that said, to think the Raiders got a first round draft pick (from a bad team no less) for Cooper as he enters the fifth year of his rookie contract (i.e. when he’s no longer a bargain) was pure magic.

While the Raiders can’t expect to replace Mack in the draft, it’s totally reasonable to expect they’ll do better than replace Cooper come April.

Which brings us to the final question facing the Raiders today: is Derek Carr next?

The franchise cornerstone on defense? GONE. The most electric offensive weapon? GONE. It’s reasonable to wonder whether the franchise quarterback is next. As far as I can tell, however, I think the answer is that Carr is going to be around for a while — and here’s why: for starters, he’s not a bargain. I don’t think he’s overpaid, but you’re not going to get a premium back for him because he’s on a rookie contract or anything. With that in mind, it’s hard to imagine the Raiders moving him for anything less than a premium.

Would the Raiders move him for a late first round draft pick? Would they even get offered that? (I would imagine they would just given the shortage of franchise quarterbacks out there, but that opinion isn’t the majority it seems). Given how long the Raiders waited for a quarterback, I find it hard to believe they’d ditch Carr so quickly — especially given his 2016 performance and the flashes we’ve seen of that this season. Add in the fact that quarterbacks are now playing late into their 30’s, Carr has a much higher likelihood of still being in his prime when the Raider rebuild is complete — which is significant.

All in all, Monday was a good day for the Raiders. Cooper is gone (yet another high draft pick down the drains), but it reflected a full commitment to the plan that — at this point — makes the most sense. Being a Raiders fan is once again synonymous with being an NFL Draft fan and well, I guess for the next couple of years that’s okay.

Follow @RaidersNationCom on social media: Facebook | Twitter | Instagram

Jeff Spiegel was raised in California but currently resides in Portland, Oregon. After graduating from the University of Oregon, he worked in sports before entering journalism full time — first as a Sports Reporter and then as the Associate Editor of a small newspaper. Online, he has been writing about both the Raiders and Dodgers since 2012 — having written for DodgersNation.com and SBNation.com prior to joining both DodgerBlue.com and RaidersNewswire.com. He left full-time journalism in 2012 to become a pastor. Jeff can be found on Twitter at @JeffSpiegel. Favorite Raider This one is an easy one for me: Charles Woodson. When the Raiders drafted him, there was nothing to dislike about the guy — he was exciting and he was freaking good. Unfortunately, of course, he left after eight seasons — but when he returned in 2013 it was one of the better Raider moments of my lifetime. At that point, I didn't care how washed he was (and he wasn't!) — I just liked having him back in the silver and black. Obviously Tim Brown is another guy that was easy to love, but Woodson is the all-timer for me. As far as current, I'm still a believer in Derek Carr and think he's going to figure this all out. Favorite Raider Moment I think I'll go with the two weeks leading up to the 2001 Super Bowl. As a kid, I remember getting the newspaper every morning to read what they were talking about, clipping out the articles to keep for later. It was obviously far more exciting than the Super Bowl itself, but I'll never forget those moments of hope leading up to the Super Bowl. I referenced it above, but second to that was probably the return of Charles Woodson in 2013 — I just loved the guy, and never dreamed he'd actually come back.
Quantcast
Exit mobile version